Blog

Which Heating System Should You Choose for Your Home in Quebec? Heat Pump, Furnace, or Wall-Mounted AC - The Complete Guide.

With the diversity of heating options available on the market, Quebec homeowners often face a complex dilemma. This technical and up-to-date guide helps you choose the optimal system for your home, taking into account the Quebec climate, government grants, and your specific situation.

Understanding Available Technologies

1. Heat Pump: The All-in-One Solution

Functionality: Heating in winter and air conditioning in summer

Scientific Principle: A heat pump uses a reversible refrigeration cycle to transfer heat rather than generate it.

• In winter: It captures thermal energy present in the outside air (even at -25°C) and amplifies it to heat your interior

• In summer: It reverses the cycle and functions as an air conditioner by expelling indoor heat

Major Advantages:

• Exceptional energy efficiency (COP of 3 to 4, meaning 3-4 kWh of heat for 1 kWh consumed)

• Complete heating/cooling solution

• Significant reduction in electricity bills compared to traditional electric heating

• Eligible for multiple grant programs

Points to Consider:

• Reduced efficiency during extreme cold (often requires a backup system)

• Higher initial investment

• Optimal performance requires professional installation

2. Furnace: Proven Power

Functionality: Heating only

Principle: Heat generation by combustion (natural gas, propane, oil) or by electric resistance

Distinct Advantages:

• Stable performance regardless of outdoor temperature

• Rapid temperature rise

• Compatible with existing duct systems

• Can integrate into a dual-energy system with a heat pump

Disadvantages:

• Does not provide air conditioning

• Generally higher energy consumption

• Annual maintenance mandatory for combustion models

• Dependence on fossil fuels (for most models)

3. Wall-Mounted AC: Simplicity

Functionality: Air conditioning only

Principle: Identical to a heat pump but without reversibility

Main Assets:

• Simple and minimally invasive installation

• Ideal solution for small spaces and apartments

• Lower acquisition cost than a heat pump

• Individual temperature control by room

Limitations:

• No heating function

• Limited coverage to one or two rooms

• Incomplete solution for year-round comfort

Detailed Comparison Table

Why Heat Pumps Are So Appealing to Quebecers

Exceptional Savings Potential

Heat pumps represent a strategic investment for Quebec homeowners, particularly in our unique energy context.

Scientific Efficiency: According to Quebec government data, for 1 kWh of electricity consumed, a heat pump can transfer 3 to 4 kWh of heat into your home at moderate temperatures (around 8°C). This performance far exceeds any form of resistance heating.

Documented Savings: The Canadian government's "Buildings" program estimates annual savings of $1,500 to $4,500 for households switching from oil to heat pumps.

Game-Changing Grants

Quebec actively encourages heat pump adoption through several financial programs:

• Hydro-Québec's LogisVert Program: Up to $6,700 for installing a high-performance heat pump

• Chauffez Vert Program: Assistance for replacing oil or propane systems with electric solutions (eligible until March 31, 2026)

• Rénoclimat: Stackable with other grants for energy efficiency work

Adaptation to the Quebec Climate

Contrary to popular belief, modern "cold climate" heat pumps maintain respectable performance down to -25°C or -30°C, thus covering most of our winter.

Decision Guide by Housing Type

Single-Family Home with Existing Central Heating

• With gas furnace in good condition: Dual-energy system (heat pump + gas furnace)

• With electric baseboards: Central heat pump with electric backup

• Without duct system: Multiple wall-mounted heat pumps + existing baseboards

Condo or Apartment

• With centralized system: Consult the condominium association

• Without existing system: Wall-mounted heat pump for main rooms

Older Home (average insulation)

• Priority to insulation work combined with an adapted heat pump

• Dual-energy system recommended for extreme cold periods

Roadmap for a Successful Transition

Step 1: Energy Audit (Essential)

Before any investment, have evaluated:

• Your home's insulation performance

• Air leaks and thermal bridges

• Compatibility of your existing electrical system

Step 2: Professional Selection

Always require:

• A valid RBQ license

• Halocarbon handling certification

• Verifiable references

• Warranty on installation and equipment

Step 3: Financial Analysis

• Obtain at least 3 detailed quotes

• Calculate return on investment: (Total Cost - Grants) / Annual Savings

• Verify grant eligibility BEFORE work begins

Step 4: Long-Term Planning

• Schedule seasonal maintenance (spring and fall)

• Carefully document your file for warranties

• Consider potential municipal regulations (noise, location)

Future Outlook and Environmental Considerations

With evolving environmental regulations and volatile energy prices, heat pumps are emerging as a future-proof solution for Quebec. Their advantageous carbon footprint, coupled with our mostly renewable electricity, makes them a strategic choice for the coming decades.

Final Recommendation: For the majority of Quebec homes, heat pumps represent the most judicious investment, particularly when integrated into a comprehensive energy efficiency approach.

Consult a certified professional for a personalized evaluation of your situation.